Tenure does not promote the retention of incompetent faculty. Each NSHE institution has a Faculty Evaluation Policy based on contractual obligations and NSHE Code. Each year Department Chairs evaluate their faculty according to these policies. Chairs are to verify that faculty are competent in teaching and/or research; engaged in ongoing professional development; and participating in shared governance and community service. If a faculty member is not meeting these contractual obligations as well as Code standards, it is the Chair’s responsibility to meet with the faculty member and remediate his/her performance. Two unsatisfactory evaluations can lead to the termination process for all faculty, tenured as well as untenured.
Tuesday, July 10, 2012
Monday, July 9, 2012
An Opposing View On The Value Of Tenure
Tenure does not create a lifetime contract between the state and tenured professors. The Nevada System of Higher Education’s Code, Chapter 6 lists the many criteria under which a tenured faculty member can be terminated. These criteria include competency in teaching and ongoing professional development. The difference then lay not in whether a tenured faculty member can be terminated, but instead in how a tenured faculty member is terminated. Chapter 6 states that tenured faculty may only be terminated for cause, such as violating or incompetently executed of one or more criterion, and must be afforded due process rights in the event of termination. As Nevada is a “right to work” state the law allows other types of employees to be terminated without cause or due process, so the only advantage tenure provides in relation to employment is tenured faculty receiving notification of the cause for termination and a process that proves the cause before being terminated. Considering the amount of education and the years of work required to be awarded tenure, cause and due process seem pretty reasonable benefits not provided for in state law.
Friday, July 6, 2012
If I Were A Legislator...
If I were a legislator or a governor and was presented with the history of tenure in Nevada, which creates lifetime employment contracts for both the competent and the incompetent, and I learned that the incompetent professors prevented the higher education system from improving as it should have, rather than hold endless meetings to try to put in a process to repair the tenure problem, I would simply do one thing. I would continue to cut funding of higher education until it either disappeared or repaired itself. My guess is that its disappearance would occur long before its repair.
Remember that tenure creates a lifetime employment contract between the university and the professor which in reality cannot be terminated by the university.
Thursday, July 5, 2012
Discussing Tenure
I know that I have spent a lot of time over the past several weeks discussing tenure. I know it has been an exercise in futility because there is no power on earth to change it. You therefore ask yourself why I spent this much time and effort in looking at the problem. My answer is simple. If you can’t get those who have created the problem to solve it; in fact, if you can’t even get those who caused the problem to understand there is a problem, then you have to go outside of the institution to solve it.
Remember that tenure creates a lifetime employment contract between the university and the professor which in reality cannot be terminated by the university.
Wednesday, July 4, 2012
Tenure Used To Protect Incompetent Employees
I receive comments from faculty members that the personnel problems at a university are different from the personnel problems in private industry. I have been in both academia and private industry. The personnel problems are exactly the same. However, the rights of an employee that protect that employee from discrimination or other illegal conduct are adequate because of present statutory law, not because of a “tenure” concept. Employers who abuse employees or discriminate against them in any manner face serious legal consequences. One difference between the private sector and academia is that statutory rights of an employee in private industry do not protect the employee from incompetence or misconduct.
Tenure can be and has too often been used to protect incompetent employees.
Tuesday, July 3, 2012
The Tool To Protect The Unimaginative
Tenure has become the tool to protect the unimaginative, uncreative, unambitious and in general the incompetent members of the faculty. Think of hiring an employee and only finding out after two or three years that the employee had no ambition, did as little as possible to perform his or her job and took advantage of every loophole in the system. As soon as you had learned that, you would fire that employee and move on. But with tenure IF YOU HIRE THEM, YOU HAVE GOT THEM FOR LIFE. Never be naïve enough to believe that you can pass them off on another university. It will not happen.
Monday, July 2, 2012
“DE-TENURING”
Over 20 years ago one of the most outstanding Regents the state has ever had proposed the elimination of tenure. The reasons were sound. But the uproar and backlash of the faculty came close to a lynching and the regent was forced to abandon the project. However, one compromise was reached and that is the Nevada process of “de-tenuring.” This process occurs when a faculty member gets two unsatisfactory evaluations in a row. I know of no professor who has ever been de-tenured and in fact when the process was tried, the professor sued and even though the system had a very strong case, it lost after spending several hundred thousands of dollars.
Tenure is alive and well and flourishing in Nevada.
Remember that tenure creates a lifetime employment contract between the university and the professor which in reality cannot be terminated by the university.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
